I hated 2009 Goudey overall. I bought a blaster and left it at that. I did pick up the Ron Santo cards in the set, with the exception of the Sport Royalty auto.
I liked the 2008 set but didn't care for the "Derek Jeter says", "Ken Griffey says" thing.
My favorite is still the 2007 set. I like the simplicity of the design. I like the various backgrounds. I don't mind that they are odd sized. In fact that's part of the charm for me. It makes them seem more authentic, even though I know they're new cards.
Upper Deck announced some basic info on the 2010 set today but did not include pictures. I look forward to seeing them.